French Constitution of 1791

The French Constitution of 1791 was a pivotal document in French history, marking the first written constitution of France and…

By Staff , in Historical Events in France , at September 24, 2024 Tags: 1791, france

Find Cheap Textbooks - Save on New & Used Textbooks at AbeBooks.com

The French Constitution of 1791 was a pivotal document in French history, marking the first written constitution of France and an essential step in the transition from absolute monarchy to a constitutional monarchy. It was enacted on September 3, 1791, by the National Constituent Assembly during the early phase of the French Revolution. The Constitution sought to limit the powers of the monarchy and establish a framework for representative government. However, it ultimately failed to satisfy both royalists and revolutionaries, leading to further political instability.

Historical Context
The French Revolution (1789):
The French Constitution of 1791 was born out of the tumultuous French Revolution, which began in 1789. Widespread social unrest, economic hardship, and dissatisfaction with the monarchy of King Louis XVI had sparked revolutionary fervor across France. The Estates-General, convened in May 1789 for the first time in over 150 years, gave way to the formation of the National Assembly, which vowed to draft a constitution that would end the absolute rule of the king.

Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen (1789):
One of the key influences on the 1791 Constitution was the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, adopted in August 1789. This declaration outlined basic liberties such as freedom of speech, equality before the law, and the protection of property, inspired by Enlightenment ideals and the American Revolution. It provided the ideological foundation for the new constitution, emphasizing individual rights and popular sovereignty.

Key Features of the Constitution
The French Constitution of 1791 created a constitutional monarchy and established a separation of powers between the executive, legislative, and judicial branches. Here are some of its key provisions:

Monarchy as the Executive:
The Constitution retained the monarchy, but with significantly reduced powers. Louis XVI remained king but was no longer an absolute monarch. Instead, he became a constitutional monarch, subject to the will of the people as expressed through the National Assembly.
The king retained the ability to appoint ministers and command the army, but his powers were constrained. For example, while the king had the power of veto, it was a suspensive veto—meaning that the king could delay laws passed by the legislature, but not indefinitely.
The king could no longer declare war without the consent of the National Assembly, reflecting the growing desire for democratic checks on royal authority.

Legislative Assembly:
The Constitution established a unicameral legislature called the Legislative Assembly, which held significant powers. This body was responsible for passing laws, approving taxes, and controlling government spending.
Members of the Legislative Assembly were elected through an indirect voting system. Active citizens—those men who paid a certain amount of taxes—had the right to vote for electors, who would in turn choose members of the Assembly. This limited suffrage was based on property ownership and excluded a significant portion of the population, including women, the poor, and enslaved people.
The Legislative Assembly was also responsible for declaring war and ratifying peace treaties, making it a key player in foreign affairs.

Judicial Reforms:
The Constitution introduced reforms to the judicial system to ensure independence from both the monarchy and the aristocracy. Judges were to be elected rather than appointed, and the judiciary was separated from the other branches of government to prevent interference from the executive and legislative bodies.

Decentralization of Power:
To reduce the centralization of power in Paris and weaken the influence of the monarchy, the Constitution promoted a more decentralized form of government. France was divided into 83 administrative departments, each with its own local governance structures. This system was intended to promote greater local autonomy and democratic governance at the regional level.

Civil Rights and Freedoms:
The Constitution incorporated the principles of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, ensuring basic civil rights such as freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of religion, and equality before the law. It also guaranteed the right to property, a key demand of the bourgeoisie.
Despite these guarantees, the Constitution did not extend full political rights to everyone. Women, slaves, and non-landowners were largely excluded from participating in the political process, as the Constitution upheld a system of limited suffrage based on wealth and property ownership.

Challenges and Shortcomings
The King’s Reluctance:
King Louis XVI was deeply reluctant to accept the Constitution, as it curtailed his authority and diminished the monarchy’s role. His attempted flight to Varennes in June 1791, where he tried to escape to Austria in the hope of raising support for a counter-revolution, severely damaged his credibility and shattered any lingering trust between the king and the revolutionaries.
Although Louis XVI was forced to publicly accept the Constitution after his capture, his reputation was irreparably damaged. Many revolutionaries saw his actions as a betrayal, and public support for the monarchy continued to decline.

Opposition from Radical Revolutionaries:
Many radical revolutionaries believed that the Constitution of 1791 did not go far enough. Groups like the Jacobins and sans-culottes wanted a republic rather than a constitutional monarchy, and they were dissatisfied with the limited scope of suffrage and the retention of the monarchy. They also pushed for more comprehensive social and economic reforms that the Constitution did not address.

Hostility from Foreign Powers:
The Constitution and the French Revolution alarmed the monarchies of Europe, particularly Austria and Prussia, which feared the spread of revolutionary ideas to their own populations. The Declaration of Pillnitz (1791) by Austria and Prussia threatened to intervene militarily in France to restore Louis XVI’s absolute power. This foreign threat increased tensions in France and contributed to the outbreak of war in 1792.

Economic and Social Problems:
Despite the progressive ideals embodied in the Constitution, France continued to suffer from severe economic problems, including food shortages and inflation. The grievances of the lower classes, especially the urban poor, were not fully addressed, leading to growing unrest. The limited voting rights in the Constitution also alienated many citizens, particularly those who were excluded from participating in the political process.

Collapse of the Constitutional Monarchy
The French Constitution of 1791 lasted only about a year before the political situation in France spiraled into greater turmoil. In 1792, tensions between revolutionaries and the monarchy came to a head when the Paris Commune and radical factions stormed the Tuileries Palace, where the royal family was being held. This event, known as the Insurrection of August 10, 1792, led to the suspension of the monarchy.
In September 1792, the National Convention was convened, and it abolished the monarchy, declaring France a republic. This marked the end of the constitutional monarchy established by the 1791 Constitution and paved the way for the Trial of Louis XVI, his execution in 1793, and the rise of radical revolutionary governments.

Legacy of the French Constitution of 1791
Although short-lived, the French Constitution of 1791 was a critical moment in the transition from absolute monarchy to republicanism in France. It reflected the revolutionary ideals of the time by establishing the principles of popular sovereignty, limited government, and civil rights. However, its failure to fully satisfy both the royalists and the radical revolutionaries, combined with the economic and political pressures of the period, led to its downfall.

The 1791 Constitution laid the groundwork for future French constitutions and was an important milestone in the broader history of constitutionalism and democratic governance. Its emphasis on limiting the power of the monarchy and empowering representative institutions would influence not only France but also other countries undergoing revolutionary change during the late 18th and 19th centuries.