History of the Miss America pageant

The Miss America pageant is a long-standing American tradition, dating back to the early 1920s. Originally conceived as a marketing ploy to extend the summer tourist season in Atlantic City, New Jersey, the event has evolved significantly over the decades, reflecting changes in American society, culture, and views on beauty, talent, and women’s roles. Today, it is recognized as a scholarship competition rather than simply a beauty contest, with a focus on education, leadership, and public service.

Origins and Early Years (1920s)
The Creation of the Pageant:
1921: Atlantic City’s Fall Frolic: The origins of the Miss America pageant can be traced back to 1921, when Atlantic City businessmen created an event called the “Fall Frolic” to extend the summer tourism season after Labor Day. This event featured a parade of young women in bathing costumes who represented various cities. The event’s success led to the idea of a more formal beauty competition.

First Miss America Contest (1921): In September 1921, the first official Miss America competition was held. It was initially called the Inter-City Beauty Contest and featured eight contestants who were judged solely on their appearance in swimsuits and evening gowns. Margaret Gorman, representing Washington, D.C., won the inaugural title and was awarded the trophy for “The Most Beautiful Bathing Girl in America.”

Early Struggles and Controversy:
Commercial Success and Challenges: While the pageant quickly gained popularity as a commercial event, it also faced controversy. Critics argued that it objectified women and reduced them to their physical appearance. The swimsuit competition, in particular, was criticized by religious and conservative groups who viewed it as indecent.

Temporary Suspension (1928–1932): Due to financial difficulties during the Great Depression and growing moral opposition, the Miss America pageant was temporarily suspended in 1928. It did not return until 1933, when interest in reviving the event as a tourist attraction grew again.

Growth and Evolution (1930s–1950s)
Return of the Pageant:
1933: Revival of Miss America: When the pageant returned in 1933, it was revamped with a new focus. Marian Bergeron, a 15-year-old from Connecticut, was crowned that year, but the competition still focused largely on beauty and appearance.

Rise of National Attention: In the 1940s, the pageant began to gain more national recognition. It was broadcast on the radio in 1935, and in 1954, the pageant was televised for the first time, bringing it to an even larger audience. The pageant was broadcast on ABC, marking the start of its long relationship with network television.

The Introduction of Talent and Scholarship:
Talent Competition (1935): In 1935, the Miss America pageant introduced a talent competition in response to criticisms that the contest was only about physical beauty. Contestants began to perform in areas such as singing, dancing, and playing musical instruments, adding a new dimension to the event and helping elevate the contestants’ roles beyond beauty.

Scholarship Program (1945): In 1945, the Miss America Organization began to offer scholarship money as part of the prize, establishing the competition as more than a beauty pageant and focusing on the educational and career aspirations of the contestants. Bess Myerson, who won the title that year, was the first (and to date, the only) Jewish woman to be crowned Miss America.

Contest and Public Image in Post-War America:
Popularity Boom in the 1950s: The pageant grew even more popular in post-war America. By the 1950s, it had become a major cultural event, symbolizing idealized American beauty, femininity, and wholesomeness. Winners were seen as role models for young women across the country.

Cold War Context: The pageant’s emphasis on morality, beauty, and success aligned with Cold War-era ideals of American superiority. The contestants were promoted as representing the best of American womanhood, in contrast to the Communist image of the Soviet woman.

Challenges and Changes (1960s–1990s)
Criticism and Feminist Protests:
1968: Feminist Protest and Miss America: The Miss America pageant faced increasing criticism in the late 1960s, particularly from the emerging women’s liberation movement. In 1968, feminists protested the pageant on the Atlantic City boardwalk, organizing a famous demonstration known as the “No More Miss America” protest. The protesters criticized the pageant for objectifying women and promoting narrow, patriarchal standards of beauty.

The Bra-Burning Myth: During the 1968 protest, women symbolically threw items like bras, girdles, and cosmetics into a “freedom trash can” to protest beauty standards. Contrary to popular belief, no bras were actually burned, but the event became closely associated with the idea of “bra-burning” and remains a pivotal moment in feminist history.

Further Evolution of the Pageant
1970s: Redefining Miss America: In response to the growing criticism, the Miss America Organization sought to redefine the pageant’s image in the 1970s. More emphasis was placed on the scholarship aspect of the competition, and the talent competition became an increasingly important part of the event. The pageant tried to position itself as a platform for young women to achieve educational and career success rather than simply as a beauty contest.

First African-American Winner (1983): A major breakthrough occurred in 1983, when Vanessa Williams became the first African-American woman to be crowned Miss America. Her win was historic, but Williams was forced to resign later that year after unauthorized nude photographs of her were published in Penthouse magazine. Despite the controversy, Williams went on to have a highly successful career in music and acting, and in 2015, she was invited back to the pageant to receive a formal apology from the Miss America Organization.

Continued Changes and Challenges
Changing Standards in the 1990s: In the 1990s, the Miss America pageant continued to evolve in response to social and cultural changes. There was increasing debate about the relevance of the swimsuit competition, with some arguing that it objectified women and others defending it as a display of fitness and health. The pageant also sought to emphasize contestants’ academic achievements and platforms for public service.

Diversity and Representation: The pageant made strides toward greater inclusivity in the late 20th century, with more diverse winners, including Suzette Charles (1984), an African-American runner-up who briefly held the title after Vanessa Williams’ resignation, and Erika Harold, who became Miss America in 2003 and is of mixed African-American and Greek descent.

The Modern Era (2000s–Present)
Reinvention as a Scholarship Competition:
Rebranding as a Scholarship Program: In the 2000s, the Miss America pageant continued to emphasize its role as a scholarship competition. The Miss America Organization promoted the fact that it was the largest provider of scholarship money to young women in the United States, awarding millions of dollars in scholarships each year. This helped to shift the perception of the pageant from a beauty contest to a platform for women to further their education and pursue leadership roles.

Swimsuit Competition Abolished (2018): In 2018, under the leadership of Gretchen Carlson, a former Miss America (1989), the Miss America Organization made a significant change by eliminating the swimsuit competition. The decision was made in the wake of the #MeToo movement and was part of a broader effort to focus more on contestants’ intelligence, achievements, and social impact. Carlson stated that the pageant would no longer judge women based on their physical appearance.

Recent Developments
Move to Streaming (2020s): The Miss America competition has struggled with declining television ratings in recent years, as pageants in general have seen a drop in popularity. In 2020, the competition celebrated its 100th anniversary, but the COVID-19 pandemic forced the event to adapt, and in 2021, the competition moved from traditional television broadcasting to streaming platforms.

Focus on Social Impact and Public Service: Today, Miss America winners are expected to champion a social impact initiative, a cause or platform they care about and advocate for during their reign. Contestants are judged on their ability to communicate, their leadership potential, and their commitment to community service.

Legacy and Cultural Impact
The Miss America pageant has had a profound impact on American culture over the past century. It has served as both a reflection of and a battleground for changing views on women’s roles, beauty, and feminism. While it has faced controversy and criticism, especially regarding its focus on appearance, the pageant has also been a source of opportunities for young women, offering scholarships and a platform to promote important social causes.

The pageant’s transformation over the years—from a beauty contest to a scholarship competition—mirrors the broader shifts in societal attitudes toward women’s empowerment and public service. Despite its challenges in the modern era, Miss America remains a notable part of American cultural history.

Advertisement:

We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.