History of United States Penitentiary, Marion

The United States Penitentiary, Marion (USP Marion), located in Marion, Illinois, has a significant and complex history as one of the most notorious federal prisons in the United States. It was originally intended to replace Alcatraz when it closed in 1963 and became known for its role in the development of supermax prison standards after a series of violent incidents and security reforms in the 1980s.

Origins and Construction (1959–1963)
Construction and Purpose: The United States Penitentiary, Marion, was constructed between 1959 and 1963, primarily as a replacement for Alcatraz, the infamous federal prison located in San Francisco Bay, which was being phased out. Alcatraz, known for housing high-risk inmates and being difficult to escape, was deemed too expensive to operate due to its aging infrastructure. USP Marion was designed to take on its role as the highest-security prison in the federal system.
Opening: The prison officially opened in 1963, the same year Alcatraz was closed. Marion quickly became the primary destination for the most dangerous and disruptive inmates within the federal prison system. Its initial role was as a high-security facility, but it eventually evolved into something much more extreme due to events in the 1970s and 1980s.

Marion as the Successor to Alcatraz (1960s–1970s)
High-Security Prison: During its early years, USP Marion functioned as a typical high-security prison, housing notorious criminals, including gang leaders, escape artists, and those involved in violent incidents in other prisons. The facility was heavily fortified, and its remote location in southern Illinois made it difficult for prisoners to escape or for outsiders to organize rescues.

Housing Notorious Inmates: The prison housed several high-profile inmates, including:
Robert Stroud, the “Birdman of Alcatraz,” who was transferred to Marion after Alcatraz closed.
John Gotti, the infamous boss of the Gambino crime family.
Pete Rose, the baseball player, who served time for tax evasion, though his case was less violent than most others in Marion.

Violent Incidents and the Lockdown of 1983
The early 1980s marked a turning point in USP Marion’s history, with events that would lead to drastic changes in how the prison operated.

Murders of Two Guards in 1983:
Violence Escalates: On October 22, 1983, two prison guards were murdered by inmates in separate incidents. Correctional Officer Merle Clutts was stabbed to death by Thomas Silverstein, a member of the Aryan Brotherhood, while Correctional Officer Robert Hoffmann was killed by another inmate, Clayton Fountain, shortly afterward. Both attacks occurred within a matter of hours and highlighted the escalating violence within the prison.
These murders underscored the growing influence of prison gangs, such as the Aryan Brotherhood and Mexican Mafia, within federal prisons. The inability to control these violent, highly organized groups within the prison system was a major issue for Marion.

Permanent Lockdown:
In response to these killings, USP Marion was placed under a permanent lockdown. The lockdown was a radical decision, and it marked a significant shift in prison management. Inmates were confined to their cells for 23 hours a day, and strict control measures were implemented to prevent further violence. This effectively turned Marion into the first “control unit” prison in the United States.
This policy of long-term solitary confinement for high-risk inmates became a model for other federal prisons, particularly those designed to house the most dangerous prisoners. Marion’s methods later influenced the development of the supermax prison concept, where inmates deemed too dangerous to be housed in traditional prisons are kept in near-total isolation.

Evolution into a Model for Supermax Prisons
The events at Marion led directly to the creation of the supermax prison model, which became the standard for housing the most dangerous prisoners in extreme isolation.

Control Unit Prison:
Marion became the first prison to fully implement the control unit model, where inmates were segregated from one another, had minimal contact with staff or other prisoners, and were subjected to intense monitoring and confinement. This was intended to control and manage inmates who posed serious threats to the security of the institution.
The purpose of the control unit was not only to isolate the most dangerous inmates but also to serve as a deterrent against future violence within the prison system.

Influence on Supermax Prisons
Marion’s practices became the basis for the design of other supermax prisons, the most notable being the United States Penitentiary, Florence ADX (ADX Florence), which opened in Colorado in 1994. ADX Florence is often referred to as the most secure prison in the United States and houses the federal system’s most dangerous inmates under conditions of extreme isolation.
The use of long-term solitary confinement and limited human contact at USP Marion set the precedent for the supermax approach to prison management, where prisoners are kept under tight control to prevent further violence or escape attempts.

Controversy and Criticism
The methods used at USP Marion, particularly the solitary confinement and the long-term lockdown, have been controversial. Critics have argued that the conditions at Marion and similar supermax facilities amount to cruel and unusual punishment due to the psychological toll of extended isolation.

Psychological Effects: Research has shown that prolonged solitary confinement can lead to severe mental health problems, including depression, anxiety, and hallucinations. The prison’s lockdown model, which involved minimal social interaction, harsh living conditions, and near-total isolation, has been condemned by human rights groups.

Legal Challenges: Over the years, there have been numerous legal challenges to the use of solitary confinement and control units, with critics asserting that these practices violate constitutional protections against cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment.

USP Marion in the Modern Era
Transition to a Medium-Security Prison:
By the late 1990s and early 2000s, USP Marion underwent a significant change in its operational status. It was downgraded from a high-security federal penitentiary to a medium-security prison, as the most dangerous inmates were transferred to newer facilities like ADX Florence.
Today, USP Marion no longer functions as a supermax facility, although it still houses inmates under high-security conditions in certain sections.

Continuing Use of High-Security Units:
Despite its downgrading, Marion still retains its high-security Control Unit, which houses prisoners who require close monitoring. The prison also has a Communications Management Unit (CMU) that restricts and monitors inmate communication, typically used for inmates with links to terrorism or organized crime.

Legacy
The legacy of USP Marion is tied to the history of prison reform, the evolution of high-security prisons, and the ongoing debate about the use of solitary confinement and control units in the U.S. prison system. The incidents of violence in the 1980s, followed by the institution’s permanent lockdown, marked the birth of the supermax prison model, a controversial approach that continues to influence how the federal prison system manages its most dangerous inmates.

Advertisement:

Bestseller No. 1

Penitentiary

• Amazon Prime Video (Video on Demand)
• Leon Isaac Kennedy, Thommy Pollard, Gloria Delaney (Actors)
• Jamaa Fanaka (Director) - Jamaa Fanaka (Writer) - Alicia Dhanifu (Producer)

Buy on Amazon

Bestseller No. 2

Penitentiary

• Factory sealed DVD
• Badja Djola, Chuck Mitchell, Thommy Pollard (Actors)
• Jamaa Fanaka (Director)

$9.78

Buy on Amazon

SaleBestseller No. 3

Penitentiary 2

• Factory sealed DVD
• Malik Carter, Joe Anthony Cox, Badja Djola (Actors)
• Jamaa Fanaka (Director)

$9.76

Buy on Amazon

Bestseller No. 4

Penitentiary 2

• Amazon Prime Video (Video on Demand)
• Leon Isaac Kennedy, Glynn Turman, Ernie Hudson (Actors)
• Jamaa Fanaka (Director) - Jamaa Fanaka (Writer) - Jamaa Fanaka (Producer)

Buy on Amazon

Bestseller No. 5

Penitentiary II [Blu-ray/DVD Combo]

• Leon Isaac Kennedy, Ernie Hudson, Mr. T (Actors)
• Jamaa Fanaka (Director)
• English (Subtitle)

$16.98

Buy on Amazon

Bestseller No. 6

Jamaa Fanaka's Penitentiary 1&2, Black Sister's Revenge, and Soul Vengeance!

• Penitentiary and more! Black film pioneer Jamaa Fanaka's four classics in one bundle.
• Leon Issac Kennedy, Mr. T., Rudy Ray Moore, Glynn Turman, Ernie Hudson, Ebony Wright (Actor)
• Jamaa Fanaka (Director) - Jamaa Fanaka (Producer)

$28.98

Buy on Amazon