Inquisition involving Galileo Galilei

The Inquisition involving Galileo Galilei was a significant episode in the history of science and religion, focusing on the conflict between Galileo’s support of the heliocentric model of the solar system and the Roman Catholic Church’s adherence to the geocentric model. Galileo’s trial by the Roman Catholic Church in 1633 represents one of the most famous clashes between science and religious doctrine.

Background: The Scientific Context
In the early 17th century, the dominant cosmological view in Europe was the Ptolemaic system, named after the Greek astronomer Ptolemy. This geocentric model posited that the Earth was the center of the universe, with the sun, planets, and stars orbiting around it. This view aligned with certain interpretations of Scripture, particularly passages in the Bible that appeared to support the notion of an Earth-centered cosmos.

However, in 1543, Nicolaus Copernicus, a Polish astronomer, published “De Revolutionibus Orbium Coelestium”, which proposed the heliocentric model. According to Copernicus, the sun was at the center of the solar system, and the Earth and other planets orbited around it. While initially this theory did not provoke much controversy, by the early 1600s, it became more widely known and debated.

Galileo and the Heliocentric Model
Galileo Galilei (1564–1642) was an Italian mathematician, physicist, and astronomer who supported the Copernican heliocentric theory. Using a telescope he had improved, Galileo made several key astronomical observations in the early 17th century that challenged the geocentric model. These included:

Moons orbiting Jupiter: In 1609–1610, Galileo discovered the four largest moons of Jupiter (now known as the Galilean moons), showing that not everything orbited the Earth.

Phases of Venus: Galileo observed that Venus exhibited phases similar to those of the Moon, which could only be explained by its orbit around the Sun, further supporting the heliocentric theory.

Sunspots and mountains on the Moon: Galileo’s observations of sunspots and the irregular surface of the Moon also contradicted the Aristotelian notion that celestial bodies were perfect and unchanging.

These discoveries provided strong evidence for the heliocentric model, and Galileo began to advocate more openly for it.

Early Conflict with the Church (1610s)
Galileo’s support for heliocentrism was not immediately condemned by the Catholic Church, but tensions began to grow in the 1610s. In 1615, Galileo wrote a letter defending the Copernican theory, arguing that the Bible should not be interpreted literally in matters of science. He stated that Scripture was written for spiritual guidance, not as a scientific authority, and therefore should not be used to contradict empirical evidence.

However, many theologians at the time believed that the Copernican system conflicted with certain passages in the Bible, such as Joshua 10:13, which describes the sun standing still. In 1616, the Roman Catholic Church officially declared heliocentrism to be “formally heretical”, as it seemed to contradict Holy Scripture. The Congregation of the Index, an office of the Inquisition, banned books supporting the heliocentric theory, including Copernicus’s “De Revolutionibus”.

Galileo’s First Warning (1616)
In 1616, Galileo was summoned to Rome, where he met with Cardinal Robert Bellarmine, a leading theologian. Bellarmine issued a warning to Galileo, instructing him not to teach or defend heliocentrism as a fact, although discussing it as a theoretical model was still permitted. Galileo complied with this order and remained largely silent on the issue for several years.

“Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems” (1632)
In 1632, Galileo published his most famous work, “Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems” (Dialogo sopra i due massimi sistemi del mondo). The book, written in Italian to reach a wide audience, presented a debate between three characters: Salviati, who argued for the Copernican heliocentric model; Simplicio, who defended the Ptolemaic geocentric model; and Sagredo, a neutral observer.

Though Galileo presented the heliocentric view as a hypothesis, the Dialogue clearly favored it and undermined the geocentric model. The character of Simplicio, a defender of geocentrism, was portrayed as somewhat foolish, which some interpreted as a veiled critique of Pope Urban VIII, who had previously been a supporter of Galileo.

The publication of the Dialogue angered the authorities of the Catholic Church, especially as it was seen as a direct violation of the 1616 injunction not to advocate heliocentrism. By this time, the political and religious climate in Europe had also changed, with the Thirty Years’ War (1618–1648) intensifying divisions within Christendom, making the Church less tolerant of dissent.

Galileo’s Trial (1633)
In 1633, Galileo was summoned to Rome to stand trial before the Roman Inquisition. He was charged with heresy for supporting heliocentrism, despite the 1616 warning. The trial took place at the Convent of the Minerva, and Galileo was interrogated by Church officials.

Charges Against Galileo:
Galileo was accused of teaching and defending the Copernican system as fact, which the Church had declared heretical. His previous warnings from the Church were also considered, and the publication of his Dialogue was viewed as a direct challenge to the Church’s authority.

Galileo’s Defense:
During the trial, Galileo attempted to defend himself by claiming that he had only presented heliocentrism as a theory and had not definitively stated that the Earth moved around the Sun. However, this defense was not convincing to the Inquisition.

Verdict and Sentence:
On June 22, 1633, the Inquisition found Galileo “vehemently suspect of heresy” for holding the belief that the Earth moves around the Sun, a view deemed contrary to Scripture. He was forced to recant his support for the heliocentric model. According to legend, after his recantation, Galileo is said to have muttered “E pur si muove” (“And yet it moves”), though there is no historical evidence for this statement.

Galileo was sentenced to house arrest for the remainder of his life. He was also required to renounce his views publicly, and his works advocating heliocentrism were banned.

Galileo’s Later Life
After his trial, Galileo lived under house arrest in his villa near Florence. Despite his confinement, he continued to work on scientific research. In 1638, he published “Two New Sciences” (Discourses and Mathematical Demonstrations Relating to Two New Sciences), which summarized much of his earlier work in physics and mechanics. This book laid the foundation for modern kinematics and strength of materials.

Galileo’s health deteriorated in his final years, and he became blind by 1637. He died in 1642, still under house arrest, but his contributions to science had already left an indelible mark.

Legacy and Rehabilitation
Galileo’s trial is often cited as a classic example of the conflict between science and religion, although modern historians have argued that the issue was more complex, involving political, personal, and religious factors.

In the centuries following Galileo’s death, the Church’s stance on heliocentrism gradually softened. By the 18th century, the heliocentric model was widely accepted by scientists, and the Church eventually lifted the ban on Galileo’s works in 1822.

In 1992, more than 350 years after Galileo’s trial, Pope John Paul II formally acknowledged the errors made by the Catholic Church in condemning Galileo. A commission set up by the Vatican concluded that the Church had acted in error when it judged Galileo, and the Pope expressed regret for how the case was handled.

Advertisement:

We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.