The Clifford-Elsey Report

The Clifford-Elsey Report, completed in September 1946, was a critical document in shaping the early Cold War policies of the United States. The report was commissioned by President Harry S. Truman and compiled by Clark Clifford, then Truman’s Special Counsel, and George Elsey, a naval intelligence officer and aide in the White House. The report provided a detailed assessment of Soviet foreign policy and the broader international situation after World War II, helping to define the emerging U.S. strategy towards the Soviet Union during a time of escalating tension.

Background and Context
In the aftermath of World War II, relations between the United States and the Soviet Union, allies during the war, rapidly deteriorated. By 1946, the optimism for a peaceful postwar order was dimming as Soviet actions in Eastern Europe, notably the imposition of communist regimes in Poland, Hungary, and other countries, raised concerns in Washington.

President Truman, seeking a coherent strategy to address these growing tensions, tasked his advisers to analyze the Soviet Union’s behavior and provide recommendations for how the U.S. should respond. Clark Clifford and George Elsey were given the responsibility of compiling a report that would summarize the state of Soviet-American relations and suggest a course of action.

Content of the Clifford-Elsey Report
The Clifford-Elsey Report was based on various intelligence documents, including diplomatic cables, policy assessments, and earlier reports like George Kennan’s famous “Long Telegram” from February 1946, which had argued that the Soviet Union’s expansionist policies were driven by deep-seated ideological and security concerns. Kennan, a U.S. diplomat stationed in Moscow, had advised the U.S. to adopt a strategy of “containment” to stop Soviet influence from spreading.

The Clifford-Elsey Report presented the following key conclusions:

Soviet Aggressiveness: The report described Soviet foreign policy as inherently aggressive and expansionist. It argued that the Soviet Union, under Joseph Stalin, was determined to expand communist influence globally, particularly in Europe and Asia. It emphasized that Soviet actions were not merely defensive but driven by ideological commitment to global communist revolution.

Soviet Control of Eastern Europe: The report pointed out the Soviet Union’s growing control over Eastern European countries, where it had established puppet regimes. This was seen as evidence of the Soviet intent to create a buffer zone and exert domination in Europe.

Global Ideological Conflict: The Clifford-Elsey Report framed the conflict between the U.S. and the Soviet Union as an ideological struggle between democracy and communism. It argued that the Soviets were not merely seeking to protect their borders but were intent on promoting communist revolutions globally.

Need for U.S. Leadership: The report recommended that the U.S. take a firm stand against Soviet expansionism and assume a leadership role in defending democracy and free nations around the world. It also emphasized the importance of economic and military strength in countering Soviet influence.

Rejecting Accommodation: One of the key takeaways from the report was the recommendation against pursuing any form of appeasement or accommodation with the Soviet Union. The report argued that Soviet ambitions could not be checked through diplomatic agreements alone, as the Soviets were committed to an ideological struggle that would continue until communism prevailed globally.

Impact and Influence
The Clifford-Elsey Report played a significant role in the formation of the Truman Doctrine and the broader U.S. strategy of containment. Its recommendations aligned with the emerging view that the U.S. needed to actively resist Soviet expansion rather than attempt to negotiate or accommodate Soviet power. This shift toward a more confrontational stance against the Soviet Union marked the beginning of the Cold War era.

The Truman Doctrine (1947): Just months after the Clifford-Elsey Report was completed, President Truman announced the Truman Doctrine in March 1947. In a speech to Congress, Truman declared that the U.S. would provide economic and military aid to countries threatened by communism, specifically Greece and Turkey at the time. This policy became the foundation of U.S. efforts to contain communism, not just in Europe, but around the world.

The Marshall Plan (1947): The Clifford-Elsey Report also influenced the development of the Marshall Plan, an economic aid program to help rebuild war-torn Europe and prevent the spread of communism. By strengthening the economies of Western Europe, the U.S. hoped to create stable, democratic allies that would resist Soviet influence.

The National Security Act of 1947: The report contributed to the creation of key U.S. national security institutions, including the National Security Council (NSC), the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), and the Department of Defense through the National Security Act of 1947. These institutions played central roles in coordinating U.S. military, intelligence, and foreign policy during the Cold War.

Advertisement:

No products found.

We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.